Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Essay 3 Rough Draft



SMOKE SIGNALS

Resentment can be a heavy burden on a person that has not found a way to let go. Forgiveness is the only thing that dissolves the resentment and provides freedom from those negative feelings. Recovery from these resentful thoughts can only come when forgiveness has been achieved. Strength is required to forgive and let go of those bitter thoughts and feelings and clear a path for a positive mine-set going forward.

Forgiveness was significant in the movie “Smoke Signals” as Victor has held on to his resentment toward his father since he was a young boy. Arnold, Victor’s father, left because the immense amount of guilty for starting a house fire due to his alcoholism. It appeared that Arnold at first dealt with his guilt through drinking more alcohol which also causes him to become violent toward his wife. This is the way he was able to mask over his guilt and still be around for his family. This all came to a head one day and Arnold gave up the battle, packed up and left. Arnold’s love for his son was present when he was getting in his truck to leave and Victor runs out and Arnold stops and gives him a big hug goodbye. This shows his love for his son even though he is choosing the cowardly way and leaving. I think he left for reasons that allowed him to survive with his own feelings, and in a way, it was a protection in order for his son to live without seeing his father’s guilt daily. But Arnold might not have thought about the lasting effects this would have on his son at such a young age growing up without a father around. A young boy without his father can create many negative emotions such as anger, hostility and resentment.

Victor’s ability to forgive his father all stemmed from the information he learned when he arrived in Arizona to receive his fathers asses and possessions. A good friend of Arnold, Suzy, was there at the trailer. Victor spend a significant amount of time with her discussing the feelings of Arnold. In doing so, Victor finds out that his father was very remorseful and thought of his son everyday; Arnold very much loved his son. This was important for Victor to learn to be able to recover from resentment he had held inside towards his father for all these years. In turn, this helped Victor to forgive his father and let go of the pain. There must have been a sweet release of negativity as Victor let go of his father ashes over the bridge in Spokane. That is the pivotal moment in Victor’s life where he can let go of his resentment and move on to happier, more positive things in his life.

As we reflect on the movie “Smoke Signals”, we can appreciate the healing power that forgiveness can play in one’s life. Forgiveness can be a difficult thing to accomplish but in the end is well worth the effort. Forgiveness helps all involved and helps release the resentment or grudge that has been bogging one down emotionally. It is in everyone’s best interest to forgive when possible. Life is short and you never know when it will be your last day.

5 comments:

  1. Mindy,
    I really liked your essay, it was easy to find your statement and you did a great job of reviling the evidence needed to back it up. I know that we should be giving positive and negative feed back, but all I could find was positive great job.!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great layout, your first comment was underestimating, because you really did a great paper!! We must always know that we need to understand our fathers and possibly that they may not have meant to hurt us...we need to recognize the hurt but let it go!! thanks for the reading!! Daye

    ReplyDelete
  3. Mandy,

    I strongly agree with you when you say that forgiveness is not easy. It require plenty of strength. If it was easier to forgive, we all wouldn't have such a hard time letting things go when others wronged us. Victor is a good example of the great effort that goes into letting go of pent up resentment.

    You have a good start, but your first paragraph needs a bit of work. It's good and it does have a thesis sentence, but you don't mention the film at all. The film isn't mentioned until the second paragraph. It would be best to combine the first two paragraphs. At the least to add a little more to the introductory paragraph.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Mandy,

    You did a great job on your introduction and conclusion paragraphs really focusing on the relationship between Victor and his father. My one positive criticism I would say is that you didn't mention that part of Victor's resentment towards his father had to do with Thomas. There was definitely some jealousy there like I mentioned in my essay. Thomas was a factor in Victor's harsh feelings towards his father. Thank you for your time.

    ReplyDelete
  5. 1. What is the writer’s thesis? Can you find the statement? Is it the main point the rest of the essay works to develop?

    Strength is required to forgive and let go of those bitter thoughts and feelings and clear a path for a positive mine-set going forward.

    2. What evidence is cited to prove and support the writer’s thesis? What pieces of evidence are cited from the readings and/or the writer’s observations to support the thesis?

    You have a lot of great evidence. I think that you should put in something about the forgiveness between Thomas and Victor.

    3. Is the writer’s reasoning/critical thinking provided to explain how the evidence proves and supports the thesis?

    Yes. Good job on using your critical thinking.

    4. What else could the writer cite as evidence in this essay?

    Like I said in answer to question 2, cite some of the forgiveness between Thomas and Victor. Thomas forgives Victor for a lot.

    6. What’s strong about the essay?

    Introduction is very strong.

    7. What other suggestions or feedback do you want to provide the writer?

    ReplyDelete